She has no personality and no opinions of herself, the bulk of the book is comprised of the opinion of the men Henry, John, the General and of her continuously saying how she simply doesn't know anything. This was way back in high school, but I distinctly remember not hating the book! This might have been because I am obsessively in love with the movie I've seen it over ten times , but I didn't find the book boring or the prose unbearable.
I had the exact opposite situation with Northanger Abbey, unfortunately. Ostensibly about a young girl named Catherine whose love of Gothic novels leads her into awkward situations at said Abbey, it is actually just the tale of Catherine hanging out in Bath, making some friends, hanging out at the Abbey for like half a minute, then getting married.
I was bored out of my goddamn mind. I mean before she gets to the Abbey it's literally just a bunch of people taking walks and going to parties and dancing and getting to know each other. When she does get to the Abbey, her imagination runs wild for like a chapter, and then everything is fine again. There's some drama with her brother being engaged to a friend of hers which was probably the most interesting thing to happen in the book. I will grant that the story had some well-developed characters and clever tongue-in-cheek humor at times.
She and her brother are both insufferable in a very entertaining way, especially when Catherine is totally ignorant of their faults. There's a lot of funny commentary on the way women are perceived and various mocking of Gothic novel tropes which I enjoyed. Unfortunately his could not save it for me, especially given the state of the prose. The prose twisted and turned and was never-ending - finish a goddamned sentence for God's sake! The long, overbearing sentences made it very difficult to focus. I also really hated the narration, which often referred to "our heroine" and talked directly to the reader in such a way that was jarring and consistently forced me out of the narrative.
Add to that was boring and uneventful the story was, the book ended up being one hell of a slog that I had to force myself to finish. I'm the first to admit that, while I did surprisingly enjoy Pride and Prejudice , I am not the biggest fan of Austen. I hated Mansfield Park when I read it last year, and while Northanger was considerably better, I still wouldn't exactly rave about it.
New PDF release: The Annotated Northanger Abbey
For a start, the content wasn't anything that I was really interested in. I was bored reading about Catherine's exploits and meetings with the Thorpe's and Tilney's in Bath, and then the titular 'Northanger Abbey' didn't appear until the l 2. I was bored reading about Catherine's exploits and meetings with the Thorpe's and Tilney's in Bath, and then the titular 'Northanger Abbey' didn't appear until the last third - and was pretty disappointing when it did. I could see that Austen was clearly drawing on the popular conventions of 18th century Gothic fiction - her characters even extensively discuss Ann Radcliffe's novels - and pokes fun at them through subverting both Catherine and the reader's experience and expectations.
I didn't care for any of the characters - Henry and Eleanor Tilney felt pretty bland, even though they were obviously supposed to be the "good" to the Thorpes' "bad" using those terms very loosely. Realistically though, Isabella Thorpe seemed like much more fun than boring old Eleanor Tilney. Catherine, while thankfully not one of those 'heroines of sensibility', was pretty boring and forgettable, though her exploits until the age of ten including rolling down grass hills, playing cricket, and just generally being "unlady-like were more interesting than anything else she did in the novel.
Plus, she fell in love with Henry in a ridiculously short period of time, and it's been a while since I've rolled my eyes that hard. In conjunction with this, the ending felt extremely rushed - all for the sake of providing a neat little conclusion - and General Tilney's expulsion of Catherine and the reason for it felt like it was simply created for the sake of unnecessary drama and to keep Henry and Catherine apart for a grand total of I guess that while I'm glad I read it to at least cross it off a TBR list of popular classics, it's not a novel that I'll be looking to re-read any time soon - if at all.
After a long spell of ignorantly sort of passively blowing off Jane Austen as the proto-chicklit author so many nabobs seem to mistake her for, I started to catch on to a little bit of what makes her important and special and much more punkily it's a word! Could it be that the fadsters who quixoitcally claim her as a godmother of Candace Bushnell and whatever-the-fuck-else are actually just dumb and missing the point entirely?
This next few months I aims to find out for myself. I started to get a sense of why she's so beloved when I started to peruse excerpts of her work here and there and see a few scandalously approving criticisms and quotations. I have, in fact, made a room full of people entirely male, mind, and non-literary and of all ages, to boot laugh approvingly while reading only a few pages of her stuff aloud. Could it be that the in decorous miss Jane might actually be one of the snarky wall flowers of this world, slouching by the punchbowl of the great world's rec room party, hair did but not done, making assiduously ascerbic comments on the foolishness of humankind, freshening up her gin and tonic with a dash of her pen's pinpricked blood?
Hmmm, worth checking out. Especially since I've got a few copies of her books lying around which I came upon entirely by accident and for free. I'm giving Northanger Abbey two stars. I'm not entirely finished yet, but I'm going to be very soon. This isn't to say I don't like it- that would be for the one star, thank you very much "am I the only one around here who gives a shit about the rules"!? I like where she's coming from; a few sharp one-liners and some sly social criticsm I mean, figuring out who marries who and who's going to flirt with you at the Pump House social is important if and when there's really something at stake- here, it's C.
M and the relative naievte of a country lass at first blush with casual venality and she does keep the story going forward pretty smoothly and at a clip. My problem is, the plot twists are a little bit telegraphed and don't land with much more than a minor thud. You mean so-and-so was building up his love interest only to let her down at the last minute? Our flirtatious, nigh-sybaritic friend Isabella is going to throw one suitor overboard when another bloke starts to give her the eye? Catherine has read too many Gothic novels and thinks that somehow the Tilneys are hiding a haunted secret?
- Donau-Walzer (On the Beautiful Blue Danube Waltz), Op. 314 (viola part) - Waltz - Op. 314 - Viola?
- The Annotated Northanger Abbey.
- A Shadow of Wings.
Austen, at least in this novel, might be considered to have caught a glimmer of what these other eminent ladies had powerfully and memorably intuited- but only a glimmer. The structure of the book doesn't really hold up enough to justify what's most interesting and incisive about her outlook on the social weave of money, sex and power.
I don't think she writes in a political vacuum, in other words, nor does she need to especially go in either direction. Apparantly Kingsley Amis remarked that he didn't like Austen all that much because she includes so little of what's really important and emphasizes so much of what's not. I leave you, dear reader, to make of that what you will I don't need Austen to wield a hammer or a sickle, just a pen will do, but I'd be mighty interested if the uncrowned queen of suburban bourgeois dramedies brought her "A" game and unsheathed her rapier wit a little more effectively.
I know she's got it in her, I just don't know if I'm missing it or if it's not necessarily there to be seen. I loved the first 70 pages or so, so it's not like I'm blowing the book off Like all books of that designation, they sit there on my little Olympus, pristine in their un-readedness, mocking and awaiting the day I go to quench my ignorance Looking forward to checking it out I also have been annoyed with myself for some time in that my reading habits haven't necessarily included as much woman writers which is to say, writers who can be distinguished from males by way of chromosome, at least as they should.
Anybody with chops has got a crack at transcendent literary genius, of course, and it's a damn shame that I haven't had as much exposure to literature written by women as I ought to. Going to correct this as much as possible in the next few months, hopefully. Might even start a new g-reads shelf to support that designation. In the meantime, here's a fun little snippet which partially convinced me to start the necessary Austen investigations What can I say?
Join the celebration of Jane Austen novels, movies, sequels and the pop culture she has inspired
I had sort of high hopes, because the back of the book made it sound like Anne of Green Gables. It was well written, although it's not the sort of writing I have much patience with. It could be funny at times, and unintentionally funny at others like every time Catherine cried. However, the plot and the characters were god-awful. Catherine, the heroine, was supposed to be this out of What can I say? Catherine, the heroine, was supposed to be this out of the ordinary heroine, but she was pretty standard, even back when it was written.
She was so annoying and I lost patience with her rather quickly.
The "Bad" characters were the best, because at least they were funny. It was all about people meeting each other and talking, then meeting each other in another place and talking. The climax was taken care of in ten pages, and the rest was more boring talking and meeting or is it meeting and talking? This was supposed to be a satire on Gothic novels, but the satire covered maybe thirty pages at the most. The rest was mundane bourgeois talk. Alas, I finished the whole book, and will never see another page of Northanger Abbey as long as I live.
Un po' coming-of-age, un po' comedy-of-manners, un po' parodia del genere sentimentale, un po' di quello gotico. Un bel compendio di generi per il primo libro di Jane Austen e per me forse anche l'ultimo. View all 3 comments. Tilney, you love Catherine because she loves you, and she probably loves you because you're the only half-decent dude she's met so far eww, John Thorpe.
- Northanger Abbey.
- Clever: Leading Your Smartest, Most Creative People.
- Paul and his Letters (Proclamation Commentaries).
- Top 10 Homeschool Questions Answered!
- Post navigation?
- The Annotated Northanger Abbey!
- One Night With Him!
And I, I don't even like either of you much, to be honest. Congrats on the marriage, I guess. Well I have to say this is my least favourite Austen. The jabs at gothic conventions were kind of amusing, but none of the characters really caught my attention. I just didn't care about any of them. I also don't especially like being in the position of knowing more than the main character for the entire book and feeling like I'm supposed to be laughing at her. I mean, I love Austen's wit, but I wanna laugh at stupid dudes, not the protagonist. Austen books are soap operas in book form.
Guilty pleasures, easy to take in, but do not provide much else. I didn't love this or hate it, it was an entertaining enough read minus the idea of a 17 year old falling in love with the first guy she meets yawn. Jul 21, hannah renee. As much as this is very markedly a work of Austen, it lacks the spirit and life that her other works such as Pride and Prejudice has.
It's Jane Austen, what's not to like? I am not sure what went wrong, it just didn't work for me. Brilliant writing but a very underwhelming story. Getting through this book was a tedious exercise. I previously enjoyed this a lot. Saya selalu berada di antara perasaan benci dan suka dengan buku-buku klasik. Ini adalah buku kedua dari Jane Austen yang saya baca dan tentunya buku pertama yang saya baca yang sangat legendaris dan tak lain dan tak bukan adalah Pride and Prejudice yang membosankan bagi saya. Sampai sekarang pun saya tidak paham kenapa banyak pembaca wanita yang tergila-gila akan Mr.
Saya mencoba peruntungan saya di buku Jane Austen kedua ini dan entah kenapa pada akhirnya saya menganggap buku ini sangat membosankan dan terjemahannya sangat kaku sekali. Mungkin buku-buku yang wanitanya banyak ngobrol dan rumpi di kala dansa dan setiap malam wanita dansa di pesta sana sini tidak cocok untuk saya. Hal-hal seperti itu menjengkelkan buat saya dan terasa buang-buang waktu dan menjadi adegan yang gak penting di dalam buku. Sejauh ini saya masih lebih suka Anna Karenina Meski baru membaca buku pertamanya sih. Inti ceritanya si Caroline ini datang ke Bath untuk mencari lelaki idamannya yang sebenarnya ia tertarik dengan Mr Tilney tetapi dia salah sahabatan sama si Isabel yang berdrama dan abangnya Isabel yang gak suka si Caroline ini naksir kepada Mr Tilney.
Isabel ini juga sangat menyebalkan karakternya buat saya. Ada adegan dia yang tidak jadi menikah dengan abangnya Caroline ini. Best Northanger Film Version? Adding page numbers 2 15 May 01, Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen 4 stars 5 17 Jan 11, Northanger Abbey - Kap. Jane Austen was an English novelist whose works of romantic fiction, set among the landed gentry, earned her a place as one of the most widely read writers in English literature, her realism and biting social commentary cementing her historical importance among scholars and critics.
Austen lived her entire life as part of a close-knit family located on the lower fringes of the English landed gentry Jane Austen was an English novelist whose works of romantic fiction, set among the landed gentry, earned her a place as one of the most widely read writers in English literature, her realism and biting social commentary cementing her historical importance among scholars and critics.
Austen lived her entire life as part of a close-knit family located on the lower fringes of the English landed gentry. She was educated primarily by her father and older brothers as well as through her own reading.
New PDF release: The Annotated Northanger Abbey - Ofitsial'nyi Book Archive
The steadfast support of her family was critical to her development as a professional writer. Her artistic apprenticeship lasted from her teenage years until she was about 35 years old. Should a properly filed counter notification be filed, you will be notified and have 10 business days within which to file for a restraining order in Federal Court to prevent the reinstatement of the material. All required fields must be filled out for us to be able to process your form. We help people distribute information and art spanning a wide range of subject matter while providing a safe, friendly, respectful, and serious site for all content creators.
Since our community serves a broad range of ages, we do not encourage content that could make a majority of our users uncomfortable. If you are sure that this product is in violation of acceptable content as defined in the agreement or that it does not meet our guidelines for General Access, please fill out the form below. It will then be reviewed by Lulu Staff to determine the next course of action.
Identify in sufficient detail the copyrighted work that you believe has been infringed upon for example, "The copyrighted work at issue is the image that appears on http: Identify each web page that allegedly contains infringing material. This requires you to provide the URL for each allegedly infringing result, document or item. I have a good faith belief that use of the copyrighted materials described above as allegedly infringing is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
I swear, under penalty of perjury, that the information in the notification is accurate and that I am the copyright owner or am authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed. Your digital signature is as legally binding as a physical signature. If you use a digital signature, your signature must exactly match the First and Last names that you specified earlier in this form. This form does not constitute legal advice and nothing that you read or are provided on this web site should be used as a substitute for the advice of competent legal counsel.
If someone believes in good faith that a Lulu Account Holder has infringed their copyright, they can request that we take down the infringing material by filing a DMCA Notice. When a clear and valid Notice is received pursuant to the guidelines, we will respond by either taking down the allegedly infringing content or blocking access to it, and we may also contact you for more information. If you are not the copyright holder or its agent and if the content is clearly infringing the copyright of a well-known work, please select "Infringes a well-known work" from the dropdown menu.
Lulu Staff has been notified of a possible violation of the terms of our Membership Agreement. Our agents will determine if the content reported is inappropriate or not based on the guidelines provided and will then take action where needed. Thank you for notifying us. The page you are attempting to access contains content that is not intended for underage readers.
See a Problem?
Northanger Abbey is the coming-of-age story of a young woman named Catherine Morland. The two Books differ significantly from each other in setting and, to a degree, in tone. Book I begins when the Allens, family friends of the Morlands, offer to take Catherine with them to Bath, a resort for the wealthier members of British society. The year-old Catherine eagerly accepts the Allens' invitation.